A tragic hit-and-run crash on All Souls’ Day in 1921 claimed the lives of two beloved music teachers from St. Joseph’s Academy in Des Moines, leaving the community in mourning and sparking an investigation that ultimately ended without anyone being convicted.
Sister Mary Virginis, born Mary Agnes Austin, and Sister Mary Rosalita, born Agnes McLaughlin, were returning to the academy after running errands on the evening of Nov. 2, 1921. As the two women attempted to cross Grand Avenue near 31st Street, they were struck by a large sedan turning onto the boulevard. Witnesses said the vehicle briefly stopped before speeding away from the scene.
Sister Mary Rosalita died almost instantly, while Sister Mary Virginis later died at Mercy Hospital from severe injuries. The deaths shocked Des Moines residents, especially students and families connected to St. Joseph’s Academy, where both sisters had spent years teaching music and mentoring young women.
Funeral services drew hundreds of mourners, including fellow nuns, students, alumnae and members of the Catholic community. The case also drew intense public attention as investigators searched for the driver responsible for the deadly crash.
Authorities later questioned local businessman William H. “Herb” Halpenny after witnesses reportedly connected his vehicle to the incident. However, conflicting witness accounts and a lack of definitive evidence led a grand jury to decline an indictment. No one was ever convicted in the case, leaving the deaths officially unsolved.
Both sisters were remembered for their dedication to education and music. Sister Mary Virginis was known for her vocal talent and leadership in the academy’s vocal department, while Sister Mary Rosalita was recognized as a gifted pianist and organist who spent most of her career teaching at the school.
Story based on reporting by Nancy Bowers for Iowa Unsolved Murders: Historic Cases.
