A brutal and still-unsolved murder in Mason City claimed the life of a respected businessman and war veteran nearly six decades ago.
Andrew “Andy” T. Hatges, 75, was found dead inside his home at 108 Virginia Avenue SE on March 9, 1968. Hatges, a well-known grocery store owner, Greek immigrant, and World War I veteran, was believed to have been killed around midnight the night before.
The discovery came after a bread delivery driver noticed Hatges’ West View Market had not opened as usual Saturday morning. Concerned by the unusual circumstances, authorities were notified and entered Hatges’ home, where they found him lying face down on the living room floor. Investigators determined he had suffered severe head injuries and a fatal throat wound. Evidence suggested he fought fiercely against his attacker before succumbing to his injuries.
Police quickly launched an extensive investigation, bringing in assistance from the Iowa Bureau of Criminal Investigation and the FBI. More than 400 interviews were conducted, and investigators searched for leads involving a red truck believed to be connected to the case. Although robbery appeared to be the motive, the person responsible was never identified. The murder remains unsolved today.
Hatges’ life was a classic American success story. Born in Greece in 1892, he immigrated to the United States as a young man and eventually settled in Iowa. After serving in the U.S. Army during World War I, he became a naturalized citizen and built a successful grocery business in Mason City. Over the years, he operated several markets and became a respected figure in both the local business community and the city’s Greek-American population.
Beyond his business achievements, Hatges was known for his dedication to family, church, and community service. He played an active role in the Greek Orthodox Church and the American Hellenic Educational Progressive Association, helping raise money for charitable causes and wartime efforts. He also helped family members establish themselves in the United States, including a nephew who later became a successful business owner.
Hatges’ death shocked Mason City and left a lasting impact on those who knew him. Former Mason City Police Chief Wes Greenan later recalled the crime as one of the most violent cases he had ever encountered. Despite decades of investigation, no arrests have been made, and the murder of Andrew Hatges remains one of Iowa’s enduring unsolved mysteries.
Source: Nancy Bowers, Iowa Unsolved Murders: Historic Cases.
