40.9 F
Ottumwa
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
Home Local News Featured Stories Tune into the Past with Ottumwa Radio: The Unsolved 1924 Murder

Tune into the Past with Ottumwa Radio: The Unsolved 1924 Murder

0
2

Nearly 102 years ago, the body of a 27-year-old Marshalltown woman was discovered in the Iowa River, launching an investigation that left behind more questions than answers.

On September 28, 1924, two hunters searching for game along the Iowa River near the Chicago Great Western Railroad Bridge, south of Marshalltown, discovered the body of a woman caught in the roots of a tree extending over the water.

The woman was later identified as Erma Vivian Caldwell, a divorced mother of five young children who worked as a waitress in Marshalltown. She was discovered just one day after her 27th birthday.

Caldwell had last been seen on August 19, 1924, leaving her rooming house at 105 East Church Street with two men. A statewide search had been conducted after her disappearance, but authorities were unable to locate her.

Investigators later searched an abandoned shack near where her body was discovered. Inside, they found a woman’s apron draped over a chair. The discovery raised additional questions about whether Caldwell had visited the shack before her disappearance and whether foul play had occurred.

Her death prompted widespread speculation. Some believed alcohol may have played a role, while others questioned whether she had accidentally fallen into the river, taken her own life, or been murdered.

Authorities ordered Caldwell’s body exhumed in October 1924. Medical experts at the State University of Iowa examined her lungs and stomach for evidence of poisoning.

Testing found no evidence of poison. An examination of her lungs found sand and vegetation, which experts said suggested she had drowned.

On November 10, 1924, Marshall County Sheriff J.R. Meekins announced that medical experts concluded Caldwell had entered the Iowa River alive and drowned.

Despite that conclusion, questions surrounding the circumstances of her death remained. Records in the Marshall County Sheriff’s Office reportedly classified her death as a murder, although newspapers at the time reported that investigators had found no evidence proving foul play.

Caldwell was initially buried in Marshalltown before being reinterred at Green Mountain Cemetery in Green Mountain, Iowa, where her parents lived.

Her five children were separated following her death and raised by different family members and households.

Family members continued to question what happened to Erma Caldwell. Some relatives reportedly believed her former husband, Harry Caldwell, may have been involved, although investigators at the time did not consider him a suspect.

Nearly a century later, the circumstances surrounding Erma Vivian Caldwell’s death remain a mystery.

Source: Historical research and article written by Nancy Bowers, March-April 2020. Information used with credit to Nancy Bowers.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here